By Mansfield Frazier
Recently a very good friend — who just happens to be one of the brightest and most committed young persons in Greater Cleveland — invited me to participate in one of the salons he helps to organize; I was deeply honored that he felt I have something worthwhile to contribute to the discussion. However, in spite of the fact I wanted to participate, I turned him down.
While I certainly feel the solutions to the stratifications that exist in our society — between black and white, straight and gay, progressives and conservatives … or any others — in large part lies in communication (we simply have to talk to and get to know each other in order to discover our differences are not as huge as we might imagine), I also strongly feel those conversations have to take place in a “neutral” setting that is comfortable for everyone.
To wit: Last year I was invited to attend a “green movement” function at a popular near-Westside setting, and if you know anything about this nascent movement you also know virtually all of the people involved live far above the color line … all they see is “green” and how we can, as a community, come together to push forth an agenda to improve the lives of all Greater Clevelanders.
Nonetheless, some of the staff at the facility (which will forever remain unnamed) was not of the same mindset as the folks hosting the event. This is a place where very few (if any) persons of color frequent on a regular basis, and a couple of the employees went out of their way to make sure the few minorities in attendance knew, in no uncertain terms, we were not welcome. Now, granted, the owners of the establishment might be of a more liberal mind, but they were not the ones tending bar that night.
When I ordered a beer the young woman behind the bar looked right at me and didn’t move a muscle … she looked right through me. Of course I’ve occasionally been down this road before … but not recently since I don’t get around all that much anymore. I again ordered, and she again let me know that while she heard me, she simply was not going to wait on a black man. A male behind the bar (obviously realizing what was going on) came over and took my order, with a somewhat apologetic look on his face. But I seriously doubt if anything of a corrective nature was ever said to the woman.
To assure myself I was not being overly sensitive (something I’ve pretty much grown out of), I waited and watched to see how any of the few other minorities in attendance would be treated by the woman, and indeed, the treatment was exactly the same. We smiled knowingly at each other but said nothing.
Of course I’ve never gone back to the establishment, since at this point in my life I have zero interest in being anywhere I’m not wanted; staying in my comfort zone is very important to me. I have no desire to be some kind of latter-day civil rights pioneer or trailblazer. Fuck that.
One of the comforts that life affords me at this point in my journey is that I don’t have to deal with such nonsense anymore … even though I certainly am equipped, due to my life experiences, to do so. Self-confidence is one of my long suits (some would say I’m mentally arrogant, but I take exception to that characterization … at least to some extent) but as George Forbes once cautioned me, “don’t piss on every fireplug.” At this stage of the game I tend to overlook ignorant people and not make an issue of their obnoxious behaviors — life’s too short.
But, with that said, I do tend to be a bit more cautious about where I choose to go.
The fine (white) gentleman that invited me to the salon lives so far above the color line I seriously doubt he can even imagine that such people as the young woman behind that bar still exists … but then, he’s never experienced the overt, racist slights I (and other persons of color) have had to endure in our lives. I certainly wasn’t humiliated by the woman’s behavior, but just as certainly got the message that I (or other minorities) are not welcome … which is fine by me.
Granted, the venue my friend recently invited me to on the relatively far Westside of Lakewood where he is hosting his salon might very well be a totally integrated environment where everyone is welcomed with open arms … but somehow I doubt it. Nonetheless, he certainly would not have invited me if he didn’t think I would be perfectly comfortable.
But the simple fact is, he cannot be expected to control the behavior of the staff or other patrons, and if one of them is aggressive (or cleverly subtle) in expressing their racism, my entire evening is tainted, or perhaps shot to hell. Who needs that shit?
So, if the goal is to bring those folks of diverse backgrounds (that I referenced in the second paragraph) together — and this certainly is a noble and necessary goal if we are to tear down the walls that separate us — care has to be taken to select a venue that is comfortable and welcoming to all. The great thing is, racists are a dying breed, and a number of excellent venues now exist in Greater Cleveland where everyone is made to feel comfortable — they simply have to be utilized more as we move forward.
From Cool Cleveland correspondent Mansfield B. Frazier mansfieldfATgmail.com. Frazier’s From Behind The Wall: Commentary on Crime, Punishment, Race and the Underclass by a Prison Inmate is available again in hardback. Snag your copy and have it signed by the author by visiting http://www.NeighborhoodSolutionsInc.com.

5 Responses to “MANSFIELD: Comfort Zone”
dale l lieb
Mr Frazier, let me apologize for the ignorant barmaid. It is a shame and should be a crime for people to treat other people, regardless of the color of their skin, this way. As a former resident of the C-town area (born and raised in Lorain) I thoroughly enjoy reading your articles and can only hope actions like this do not deter you from continuing. God Bless You and keep up the good work.
mansfield
Dale,
Thanks for the kind words, I’m still as committed as ever, I just pick my places better.
Nina
If you don’t out the institution that did this, how is anything ever going to change? There are PLENTY of folks who read this of all stripes, colors and backgrounds who would be more than happy to stop going to wherever this place is, en masse, and put them out of business so that they get the message that this kind of crap is not tolerated, but if you don’t share where this happened, we can’t? Why on earth would you want to keep the name of this place to yourself? Nobody wants you to be a pioneer if you don’t want to, but many of us would like to actively not support a business like this, and we can’t make that decision if we don’t have the information.
Julie
I agree with Nina. If I knew which establishment treated you (and others) so poorly, I would go out of my way to NOT go there. And if I were the owner, assuming I wasn’t complicit in this behavior, I’d certainly want to know if one of my employees was acting this way. Not asking you to start a campaign against the place, but I’d like to know the name (or have a very strong hint) so I can avoid it and suggest to my friends that they do likewise.
bob
ULTIMATELY Only ONE green..the paper kind…’rules’ (mostly) SORRY to hear bout that one female bar keep…GOSH only knows her jazz…tooo easy to let past incidents,etc. color ones perception… I know wha saying… IS HARD very HARD to play trailblazer,pioneer,social activist… EVEN harder to go into some outfit and deal with THAT… I made mistake once of being semi casually dressed dark bluish semi work clothing and stepping into some wannabe Youngish Yup type deal over in Tremont at OFF day somewhat late in evening and felt like a Martian…..Pass all this stuff all the time and was curious as to whether any good or not….least give one barkeep a decent shake for least acknowledging me…If remember correctly got a coffee or something… the DIVIDE is THERE… hey….. wha gonna do… thou sounds like YOUR experience lot worse….
Life is hard enough… I SAVE MY *$*@ for SOME *$*@ cred card or other *$@*…excuse my French…